Viewpoint: Robert Beck – The challenge of the homefront

Robert Beck

Robert Beck COURTESY PHOTO

Published: 10-30-2024 11:31 AM

This is the seventh and final piece in a series of articles on key foreign policy challenges for the next U.S. president. 

This series of articles, which began in June, has figuratively spanned the globe, from Beijing to Lagos to Moscow to Tel Aviv to Mexico City and beyond in an attempt to present some of the key foreign policy challenges that our next commander-in-chief will likely face. Consequently, it may seem counterintuitive, but what follows will focus on homegrown impediments to the next president’s ability to pursue a coherent, over the horizon strategy for America’s place in the world. 

The political polarization that has infected this country like a metastasizing cancer has degraded America’s capacity to pursue bipartisan, common-sense foreign policies. The zero-sum nature of our political culture wars is increasingly permeating the international realm, as one party’s policy on an issue is viewed by the other party as fodder for political gain, regardless of the wisdom of the original policy.  In short, what is good for one party’s immediate election prospects is much more important than what is good for the United States of America.  Furthermore, this disunity on foreign policy is being weaponized against an unassuming and sometimes woefully ill-informed public by foreign-sponsored, elaborate disinformation campaigns and partisan media outlets. 

The breakdown in bipartisan consensus on the overarching goals of America’s place in the world has come at a cost to our ability to effectively operate on the international chessboard. Over the past three presidential administrations, we have witnessed pendulum swings in our policies toward Iran, global climate change efforts, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, Russia and security commitments to South Korea. Consequently, allies and adversaries alike are losing trust in our word when we enter into an agreement.  For example, why should the Iranians reenter serious nonproliferation negotiations with Washington if they have legitimate concerns that any accord they sign will be unilaterally abrogated by a future president?

The difficulty in formulating and pursuing long-term policies is also hampered by the weakening influence of Congress in our foreign affairs as well as systemic limitations in America’s political system.  Regarding the latter, U.S. House members no sooner clear up after their election (usually reelection) victory parties than they start campaigning for the next cycle, less than two years into the future. Their priorities tend to be short-term, not strategic. Meanwhile, the Senate’s arcane filibuster tradition is often used by obstreperous senators to slow or block nominations to key positions in the foreign policy establishment, merely to make a point on an otherwise unrelated issue.

The dearth of requisite focus in Congress on critical international challenges is exacerbated by America’s main press outlets, which offer biased, mostly simplistic coverage of often deep-seated, complex overseas imbroglios threatening U.S. interests. In defense of the networks, however, they are guided by the bottom line of the ratings, focusing on easy-to-understand stories that sell. Nevertheless, if more people appreciated the depth and importance of America’s engagement with the wider world, they would hopefully show deeper interest in events abroad. 

In another worrying trend, while China starts compulsory English-language training in grade three, the United States, according to a worldwide language index study published in 2021, ranked dead last among 30 Western countries in language learning. The essential foundation of understanding our friends and foes beyond our borders is language proficiency. Without it, we risk a future with an atrophied capacity to intelligently predict, manage and respond to international crises. 

Explaining the criticality of our international relationships calls for leadership, both by the legislative and executive branches. Thus, the new tenant in the White House will be tasked with rallying a somewhat disconnected citizenry and a rancorous, dangerously divided political establishment to gain support for responsible, long-term policies regarding our key foreign policy challenges in Europe, Asia, the Middle East and the Global South.  

Article continues after...

Yesterday's Most Read Articles

Maggie Goodlander defeats Lily Tang Williams in 2nd Congressional District
BUSINESS: Monadnock Eats brings dining and catering to downtown Peterborough
Tractor-trailer catches fire in Jaffrey
Monadnock Center seeks ‘Found!’ items
BUSINESS: Dr. Marc Winiecki looks to form relationships at Monad Doc Health Direct
Mike Harner named new executive director at Lionheart Classical Academy

Here’s wishing the next administration the best of luck in that endeavor. In closing this series, please vote.

Robert Beck of Peterborough served for 30 years overseas with the United States government in embassies in Europe, the Middle East and Asia. He now teaches foreign policy classes at Keene State College’s Cheshire Academy for Lifelong Learning.